I thought I would share a few take aways from my trip to Helena,
Montana last week. A number of very kind people collaborated to invite
me to speak at the Great Conversations dinner event in benefit of the
Helena Education Foundation, and also at Carroll College.
Unfortunately, after a public lecture at Carroll on Tuesday night, my
voice was in shambles and I had to miss several classroom visits on
Wednesday in order to rest up for the dinner. That's never happened
before, and I truly hope the opportunity will develop to return to
Carroll some day. They are a thoughtful and welcoming school.
The Systematic Nature of Consumerism.
One of the discussion points in almost all of my conversations with
folks was that consumerism is systematic in our country. Moreover, it
is difficult to buck the system of consumerism. Essentially the idea is
that our national economy and the lives of average Americans are
dependent on a wasteful form of consumerism. It is not simple for a
concerned and thoughtful person to just stop participating in the
process of consumerism, either. It's not impossible. But it sure isn't
easy.
I have many thoughts about responses to the systematic
nature of consumerism. Here are a couple. First, wanting not to
participate is a big part of the battle. It's been my personal
experience, as well as my observation, that people intuit the
wastefulness associated with consumerism is bad. But acting on that
perception is difficult for many people. Right now the problems of
consumerism are mostly described as emergencies by the media or
advocacy groups. The trouble is that emergencies are kind of easy to
forget about when it does not immediate affect you. It's doubly simple
to ignore an emergency after it passes is you are addicted to the
behavior that caused the trouble in the first place. And for many,
consumerism has all the symptoms of an addiction.
Also, changing
systems is not for the faint of heart. Perhaps there are a few special
people out there who can lead the charge to change an entire way of
doing things. This being Thanksgiving week in the United States, I
think of people like Abraham Lincoln. He was one of those unique
historical figures who could stand as an individual and lead an entire
people through the trials of systematic change. Anyone remotely
familiar with history knows the cost to Americans and to Lincoln
himself.
But systematic change has many participants. Each one
of us can do our bit. Then it is up to (in my religious views) God to
take the work of some individuals and present it to the rest of the
world for further consideration. With enough people doing their part
and the right leaders raised up, more massive systematic change is
possible. It never finishes the job this side of eternity. But it's
hopeful nonetheless. What seems most positive to me, is that an
individual or a household can go a long way toward changing for the
better even if the larger system does not move much. All of us don't
need to be wasteful consumers. We can be more thoughtful in our
economics, even while the larger system struggles.
It Ain't Cut And Dry.
I am a huge advocate for shades of meaning. Which one of us lives a
consistent life consistently? As a number of my readers pointed out in
the comments of my most recent Portraits of Our Economic Meltdown,
sweeping statements of judgment are very dangerous.
I met quite
a few people like me. Folks who know that wasteful consumerism is best
avoided. Nevertheless, all of the people I met participated in the
nastier side of consumerism to some degree. And all of them also had
stories of resisting it. Many shared poignant stories of prioritizing
family or education or nature or just simply time over consuming more
stuff. There were a ton of people who had their priorities straight.
Almost everyone avoidedWal-Mart! And yet, not a one of us were innocent.
That's
one of the things I don't like about consumerism or materialism or the
love of stuff. It breeds extreme reactions. We hear about ascetics who
rebel and give up all their possessions, dropping out of life. Others
jump fully into the sensualist lifestyle, embracing as much money, sex,
and stuff they can get their hands on. Consumerism produces people like
this, or people who think like this. But most of us aren't. We are
average as can be. And we struggle with the ups and downs of the
not-entirely-selfish people who we are. People who enjoy stuff but also
long for loving relationships more than things.
Californians Be Cautious Moving To Montana.
I didn't tell anyone in Helena, but our home group has a fantasy we'll
never act on - we want to all buy land somewhere and circle our four
ranches together to raise our kids and animals and enjoy nature
together. We've been meeting with the same group of friends every week
for twelve years. There's eight adults and twelve children. So I was
also on a scouting trip in Montana. I found out that we Californians
can get a ton of land at unimaginable prices. But there's suspicion in
Montana about our kind. To be fair, we SanDiegans don't much like people moving here, either.
I felt almost like I could relate to the folks from Montana, because there used to be cattle ranchers in Poway,
the San Diego suburb where I grew up. Now they raise Padres and
Chargers and ex-bankers in those same rolling hills where once buffalo
roamed. Considering the state of San Diego sports and the economy, you
can judge if we're better off without the all the bull...
Recent Comments